Lilly Lashes Reviews

Lilly Lashes has an overall rating of 4.0 based on 28 reviews. Customer feedback on Lilly Lashes is mixed: Lilly Lashes reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality lashes, wide variety of styles, comfortable to wear, excellent customer service, which strongly appeal to makeup enthusiasts, beauty professionals, individuals seeking premium lash products. However, Lilly Lashes is often criticized for its higher price point, limited international shipping options, occasional stock issues, some styles may not suit all eye shapes.

4.0/5.0

28 reviews

5 Stars

15

4 Stars

0

3 Stars

9

2 Stars

3

1 Star

0

All Lilly Lashes Reviews (28)
EvaLusher_73
May 19, 2026
"Lasted way longer than I expected!"
I wore mine the whole weekend and they still looked really good :) The glue came off super easily too, and they didn’t get weird or bent out of shape. Happy with them tbh!
InMullins_90
May 16, 2026
"My refund took forever"
I ordered the lashes they were really cute when they arrived. But when I had to make a return, the whole process ended up being way more annoying than I expected. I kept checking for my refund and it felt like it took forever to finally show up. As much as I liked the lashes, I’m not sure I’d want to go through that hassle again...
RAY
May 09, 2026
"Easy to Browse and Find What I Needed"
I was shopping for lashes and found the site really easy to get around. I’ve used other beauty sites before where the pages feel cluttered or the photos take forever to load, so this was a nice change. The pictures loaded quickly, the different styles were easy to compare, and the checkout page looked straightforward. I also appreciated that there weren’t any annoying pop-ups or confusing steps. Overall, it was a smooth experience
sherry.Posey
May 05, 2026
"These lashes are really nice, and..."
These lashes are really nice, and I feel like the quality matches the price. They look good on and make me feel put together without trying too hard. I’d say they’re a solid buy for sure
Stephanie_smith99
April 21, 2026
"Feels real enough"
Seems legit overall. Took me a little while to actually trust it, though
DEBARROS
April 17, 2026
"Good for my sensitive eyes"
My eyes get irritated easily with lashes, so I wasn’t sure about these. I wore them all night and didn’t end up with that scratchy, red feeling.

They felt light, stayed put, and came off without pulling. Happy with them.
jillscott3686
April 12, 2026
"Looks nice, but not the comfiest"
I liked how they looked when I first put them on, and they definitely do the job style-wise. But after a few hours, they started to feel a bit heavy on my eyes. The band also poked me here and there, which got annoying quickly. I’d probably wear them for a short outing, but definitely not all day
CharlesBader
April 09, 2026
"So many lash styles to choose from"
I was happy with how many options Lilly Lashes had. I wanted something that wasn’t too dramatic for everyday wear, but I noticed they also have fuller, bolder styles if I ever feel like switching it up.

The site was easy enough to browse, and I liked that I could compare different shapes and lengths without feeling overwhelmed. They had wispy pairs, cat-eye styles, and simpler ones too, which made it easier to find what would actually work for me.

I ended up ordering a few different looks, and they all felt different in a good way. It’s a nice option if you get tired of wearing the same lash style all the time. That said, after trying a few and leaving honest feedback, I definitely wouldn’t say no to a little store credit or discount for my next order
RickFaulk_26
April 08, 2026
"Pretty lashes, but the price sneaks up on you"
I do really like how the lashes look once they’re on, they’re cute and the quality is decent. But the price feels a little high, especially once shipping and all the little extras get added. It kind of feels like you think you’re paying one amount, then suddenly it’s more than expected. They’re not bad at all, I just don’t know if I’d buy them regularly unless there was a sale. For what I paid, I was expecting a bit more.
stellapaul1582
April 01, 2026
"I wanted big, dramatic lashes for my night..."
I wanted big, dramatic lashes for my night out, and these gave me exactly that. They made my eyes stand out so much without feeling too heavy, which I loved because I still wanted to feel comfortable all night. It took me a little bit to get them on, but once they were in place, I thought they looked really good on me. I’d definitely buy them again.
clarakawamoto6373
March 31, 2026
"My lashes got here exactly when they..."
My lashes got here exactly when they said they would. Wasn't no hassle or anything, just a smooth delivery.
ElvaAdkins_78
March 27, 2026
"Pretty good lashes, honestly"
These lashes are actually really soft and held up better than I expected. Kind of makes me wonder why some other ones I’ve bought feel so cheap, but these were nice tbh.
hello_john521
March 18, 2026
"Looks really natural"
It’s really not too much, just a everyday look. I like how natural it feels.
JesusGary_98
February 18, 2026
"They do look nice once they’re..."
They do look nice once they’re on, so I’ll give them that. But the band felt a bit stiff to me and wasn’t as flexible as I expected. I had to spend extra time adjusting them to get them to sit right, which was a little annoying. Not bad overall, just not sure I’d reach for them when I’m in a hurry.
Charles.schafer
February 06, 2026
"My order was spot on"
I ordered a few pairs of lashes from lillylashes.com , and everything showed up exactly like I picked it . The styles were right , the quantity was right , and nothing was mixed up . The packaging was fine too . Honestly , I was happy because I’ve had other sites send me the wrong stuff before . I’d order from them again .
gilberto-Hubbard
February 03, 2026
"Just got it and the packaging was a letdown"
Mine arrived today, and the first thing I noticed was the box being crushed. Maybe I’m extra annoyed because it just happened, but it definitely made the whole experience feel disappointing right away.
Richard_landers05
February 02, 2026
"Okay, they kind of proved me wrong"
I’ve worn my Lilly Lashes pair around 8 times now and they’re still looking surprisingly good. I just peel off the glue after each wear and put them back in the case. i was ready to assume they’d lose their shape way sooner, but apparently they’re sturdier than they let on
david1974
January 18, 2026
"I was in such a good..."
I was in such a good mood when I realized how light these lashes felt. Usually after a few hours I start getting cranky because lashes feel heavy or annoying, but these didn’t bother me at all. They didn’t pull on my eyes, and they looked really natural, which I love for everyday wear. I had them on all day and pretty much forgot about them. Super happy with these
john1976
January 02, 2026
"Decent Discounts, But the Sales Could Be Better"
The discount codes are nice and they do help a bit, but the sales don’t feel that impressive. It seems like better deals would be easy to offer, so the lack of stronger discounts feels avoidable.
PamelaPaci
December 29, 2025
"These lashes fit my eyes really well and..."
These lashes fit my eyes really well and I barely had to trim them. The size looked kinda natural, and they felt comfy all day.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Lilly Lashes?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.